My Photo

Subscribe to this blog

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Get an e-mail subscription

  • e-mail subscription
    Enter your Email


    Powered by FeedBlitz
  • Google Ads

Books I Recommend

  • This is the classic book that redefined modern thinking on business innovation. A must read.


  • This is a great book on design by one of the founders of IDEO.

Tools

  • Search This Blog

Analytics

Blogroll

My Flickr

  • www.flickr.com

Hobson, Alert the Media!

Dollars I was watching Tivo on my Sony TV tonight while browsing the TechCrunch and The Loose Wire blogs on my Dell D600 laptop when what I read almost made me gag on my deliciously chewy Snickers bar. Apparently, some bloggers are being paid to promote products in their posts! I chugged a hit of pure energy from my refreshing Red Bull and read on.

PayPerPost.com is linking advertisers to bloggers with Maxim-like lubriciousness. Bloggers can find advertisers on the PayPerPost site who are offering to pay bloggers if they link to a site or review a product, and are sometimes only offering to pay if the blogger’s product review is positive. Thinking that I could learn more, I clicked on a graphic that declared “Easiest. Money. Ever.” on the TechCrunch site, but it only took me to a website trying to sell advertisements to bloggers.

I paused my Tivo, just when I was about to find out which team on The Apprentice was going to win the contest to create the best XBox 360 display at a Wal-Mart store, so that I could focus more on the story that laid beside the Intel Xeon Inside ad. I was shocked, shocked to find out that any of the 40 million bloggers out there would modify their content for money.

Seriously, buyer beware. This isn’t a case of “you get what you pay for,” because many of the free blogs that I read are of excellent quality and present trustworthy opinions. Still, don’t be naive, read with a critical eye. Would you be surprised to find out that people blog to promote their agenda, their book, their company, their friend’s company?

By the way, what are people being paid to blog about by these shameless capitalists? Looking at the PayPerPost list of opportunities, it looks like I could get $5 to post 50 words about public transportation, $5 to post 20 words about the TV show Hell’s Kitchen (which is god-awful…does this mention qualify me for the money?), and $10 to post 20 words about the May 20 release of the Spider Man 3 movie (damn, three words short…wait, now I’m over the twenty word requirement!).

Corante Innovation Hub

I’ve been taking a break recently, but big things have happened while I’ve been offline. Corante, a company whose website provides hubs (portals) for targeted blogs that focus on specific business themes, has just launched a new hub for innovation. Innovation Science (this blog) is a part of the new group. The Innovation Hub can be found alongside hubs for Marketing, Media and Web Technology.

In addition to providing a single site to keep up with the top blogs in these areas, Corante also provides editorial commentary on their contributors’ posts with overviews of hot topics in the respective hub areas. Other Corante initiatives include sponsoring conferences in their four main areas, such as the upcoming Innovative Marketing Conference at Columbia University’s business school.

I’m excited about being a part of the innovation group and look forward to contributing along with my colleagues. This should be pretty interesting and I expect to see some innovative applications of our expertise through Corante.

My fellow Corante Innovation Hub bloggers that you should all read are (I’ll update this list as I get more information):

Walter Baets, Complexity, Innovation, and Knowledge - http://euromed.blogs.com/baets/
Johnathan Barrett and Innosight team, Innoblog - http://www.innosight.com/blog/
Rod Boothy, Innovation Creators - http://www.innovationcreators.com/ 
Renee Hopkins Callahan, Idea Flow - http://ideaflow.corante.com/
Don Dodge on The Next Big Thing - http://dondodge.typepad.com/
Brent Edwards, Innovation Science - http://brentblog.typepad.com/brentblog/
Greg Eichenbach, Grassroots Innovation - http://grassrootsinnovation.blogspot.com/
Chuck Frey, Innovation Tools - http://www.innovationtools.com/Weblog/innovation-weblog.asp
Paul Gladen, Chief Innovation Officer - http://www.muzeview.com/cio/
Gordon Graham, Broken Bulbs - http://orxilinasia.blogspot.com/
Steve Hardy,  Creative Generalist - http://creativegeneralist.blogspot.com/
Guy Kawasaki, Signum sinne tinnitu - http://blog.guykawasaki.com/
Egils Milbergs, Accelerating Innovation - http://innovate.typepad.com/
Michael Osofsky on Innovation - http://innov8or.blogspot.com/
Alex Pang, The End Of Cyberspace - http://www.endofcyberspace.com/
Alex Pang/Paul Saffo (Institute For The Future) - IFTF’s Future Now - http://future.iftf.org/
Jeffrey Phillips, Innovate on Purpose - http://innovateonpurpose.blogspot.com/
Boris Pluskowski and Imaginatik team, Corporate Innovation Blog - http://imaginatikresearch.blogspot.com/
Douglas Rushkoff - http://www.rushkoff.com/
Paul Williams, Idea Sandbox - http://www.idea-sandbox.com/blog/
Joyce Wycoff, Heads Up On Organizational Innovation - http://thinksmart.typepad.com/headsup_on_organizational/

Similarities Between Blogging and Giving Presentations

I just returned from my industry’s largest convention (the American Academy of Audiology) where I gave a talk on cognition with Prof. Hafter from UC Berkeley. As always, the audience had a mix of backgrounds, several of whom I met after the talk.

I value these interactions that arise from responses to my presentations, as I do the ones that have arisen from responses to my blog. The vast majority of those who read my blog are not associated with my field of work, and my communications resulting from the blog have been with people whom I would have never met otherwise. Thinking about these two ways of meeting new people with common interests, I thought about the similarities that exist between giving presentations and blogging—the former I’ve done for many years and the latter just for a few months.

Ideation

For me, both blogging and giving presentations have multiple purposes. Both are forums for conveying thoughts and ideas to others, a way to communicate with several people at once on a topic of common interest. Both require that I spend time to understand the topic in a coherent way. I try to express my ideas as a compelling story and with a logical structure, requiring that I be able to give the big picture on ideas but also tie them to supportive details. Giving presentations and blogging causes me to refine my thoughts and understand the topic at hand in a more thorough way.

Dedicated Audience Members

At the conference where I just spoke, there were many competing talks on a variety of topics. Those who attended my presentation therefore made the choice to invest their time to the one-way communication: they read the program, they planned their schedule to attend, and they spent a significant amount of time listening to what I had to say. I see this as similar to people who subscribe to my blog or are repeat visitors. They actively seek to hear what I have to say in my blog posts because we share similar interests, and they dedicate a certain amount of time to reading the posts. But, while the majority of people who hear my presentations fall into this category, the majority of people who read my blog fall into the different category of…

Drive-by Visitors

By analyzing the statistics of daily visitors to my blog, I can see that most of my readers are people who found my blog from a keyword search. They most likely skim the post that they were directed to and then go back to what they were doing. My post may or may not have been what they were looking for (“Those weren’t photos of Lindsay Lohan!”), and many spent negligible effort absorbing the thoughts that I was conveying. The equivalent of this for presentations doesn’t really exist. If it did, this would be a large and slightly unreal conference where attendees jump in and out of meeting rooms based on posted titles on the door or from snippets of words they hear from the hallway, making quick judgments whether to stay and hear the whole presentation or move on to something else.

Audience Feedback

I think that both bloggers and presenters hope to receive feedback from their audience on what they say, and that usually happens when people come up and talk to you after the presentation or when people add comments to a blog post. Most blogs that I read, though—as well as my own blog—have received few comments from readers, with most posts having none at all. As with presentations, the vast majority of a blog’s audience are passive receivers of information who choose not to become active participants in the discussion. In general, only the most popular blogs receive comments on every post. This could be because those blogs are so interesting that they elicit a desire in the reader to respond while other blogs are not, but I suspect that it is simply numbers: if only 0.1% of blog readers write comments, then there will be an average of one comment for every 1000 viewers of a post. Most of us do not have that kind of traffic.

FYI, the talk I gave was very successful. About 250 people were in the audience, and someone actually yelled out a cheer at the end of it! I got to meet several interesting people afterwards, including a cognitive scientist from Brandeis University, the author of the blog HearingMojo that I link to on my Squidoo site, and audiologists whose office is close to where I work.

My Life as a Blogger, So Far...

I've been blogging for a few months now, and it's been interesting so far. I started simply because I wanted to see what blogging was like and to become more familiar with the blogging world. I have to admit that before I started I only paid attention to the few gadget and Getting Things Done blogs that I had stumbled upon.

I began my blog thinking that I would post an update on what I was doing--for my friends and family--and scientific thoughts and discoveries for those interested in hearing science. My blog quickly became an outlet for general ideas on work-related strategies, providing a connection to those with the same things on their mind as me.

Even though I'm a novice in this vast and and incorporeal space, I do feel that I'm a part of a community. I've discovered blogs by individuals with similar interests to mine, and reading their thoughts spur my own which sometimes results in my own post. And, of course, I would guess that my posts cause similar responses from others.

Conversations among bloggers aren't direct but are, by their nature, referential only. Imagine the connection that actors on stage would feel in a Shakespeare play where the dialogue consisted solely of asides, and you get an idea of the connection that exists between bloggers. It is somewhat akin to scientific journals where one scientist's paper references work in another scientist's paper, but no direct dialogue or debate between the scientists with competing theories takes place in print. The difference with the scientific world is that these scientists will usually meet and have the missing dialogue or debate at conferences associated with their field of research. In keeping with the sideways communication amongst us bloggers, I should point out that perhaps this post was a result of Irving Wladawsky-Berger's Reflections on Blogging.

One aspect that's missing from the blogging world is the ability to easily see the connections between bloggers' posts. Trackbacks allow one blog to let another know when they reference that blog, but not everyone uses trackbacks. Technorati shows which blogs link to a specific blog, but if Blog B references Blog A, and Blog C references Blog B, the connection between Blog C and A is not readily available. Thus, knowing when a blogging topic catches like wildfire and when it has limited exposure is difficult. Technorati has the database available to create a Post Map that shows all of the connections that lead from a specific post, like a spiderweb.  Such a device would be akin to threads on discussion boards or the threading feature available on Gmail to follow continuity of topic. If anyone wants to create a Web 2.0 company off of this concept, be my guest  :)